News & Comment

Archive for the 'Bad examples' Category

Consultation Institute on online only consultation

Posted by Gez Smith on Sep 02 2008 | Bad examples, Consultation, Conversations, Debate, Engagement, Good examples, Participation, Social media, web 2.0 and other buzzwords

Most of you reading will know about the Consultation Institute, and if you don’t, you should. Every other Tuesday they send out a ‘Tuesday Topic’ email to members, a short article with some thoughts, facts and ideas on an issue of relevance to consultation.

Today there was one on ‘The Online Only Pitfall’, how it’s a bad idea to run a consultation only through online mechanisms without any opportunity… read more

no comments for now

Hammersmith use Youtube too…

Posted by Gez Smith on Feb 11 2008 | Bad examples, Social media, web 2.0 and other buzzwords

Interesting venture here from the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham, promoting their budget cuts and council performance through Youtube in the form of a brief music video. Read the full media release here.

It’s not consultation as such, but the comments on the video have been left open, and in this case they don’t seem to have been used for genuine debate. Initially, the… read more

no comments for now

No internet please, we’re Japanese

Posted by Gez Smith on Jul 13 2007 | Bad examples, Democracy and government

There’s not a lot that can be said alongside this story, as it just seems so weird. Apparently all forms of online campaigning in elections in Japan are against the law, so all candidates (and by inference presumably political parties generally) are now forbidden from creating new websites or updating existing ones until July 29th.

Read the article for more on this, and wonder at the oddity of… read more

no comments for now

The title says it all

Posted by Gez Smith on Jul 09 2007 | Bad examples, Consultation, Participation

The new Department for Children, Schools and Families are running an e-consultation on the use of physical punishment. The e-consultation system doesn’t seem too bad in the scheme of government e-consultation, there are things that could be improved with it as ever, but at least it’s not just a downloadable pdf masquerading as e-consultation.

More amusing though is the banner from the front page linking to… read more

no comments for now